BACK IN
MY PAY.
Data status ↗

Bring receipts / reviewed 2026-11-15

“New houses are bigger now; that explains the price difference.”

Not established by these data

The price series alone cannot isolate size from land, quality, location and the mix of homes sold. It is not a constant-quality home-price index.

The test

Ask whether the national annual price series identifies how much of the 2016–2025 change is caused by size.

The annual new-home median changes from $307,800 to $417,400 (35.6% nominally). That is not an estimate of the effect of size.

The strongest counterargument

Size and quality can explain part of a price difference. A suitable matched or quality-adjusted dataset could help quantify that contribution.

What this does not prove

No size series is joined here. Dividing separately reported median price and median area would not produce the observed median price per square foot.

Selected endpoints are transparent; explore alternate periods and the full series in the linked tool.

The paper trail

Data periods: 2016 and 2025 annual estimates. Release release-2026-11-15-b7a8083e2af0; receipt method 1.1.0.

This claim’s receipt

Share the comparison and its context.For the group chat’s next unsolicited economics lecture.

One short paragraph and a source link for the conversation. Open the full receipt below for every assumption and source.

More formats
Claim share graphicClaim observations CSVPinned claim evidence page

For 2016–2025, more square footage may explain some of the price change, but this series can’t tell us how much. The annual new-home median changes from $307,800 to $417,400 (35.6% nominally). That is not an estimate of the effect of size. Size and quality can explain part of a price difference. A suitable matched or quality-adjusted dataset could help quantify that contribution. No size series is joined here. Dividing separately reported median price and median area would not produce the observed median price per square foot. Source: Back In My Pay — https://backinmypay.com/evidence/release-2026-11-15-b7a8083e2af0/1.1.0/claim/bigger-houses-do-not-settle-it
Full claim receipt and sources
“New houses are bigger now; that explains the price difference.”

Conclusion: Not established by these data. The price series alone cannot isolate size from land, quality, location and the mix of homes sold. It is not a constant-quality home-price index.

The annual new-home median changes from $307,800 to $417,400 (35.6% nominally). That is not an estimate of the effect of size.

Test: Ask whether the national annual price series identifies how much of the 2016–2025 change is caused by size.

Counterargument: Size and quality can explain part of a price difference. A suitable matched or quality-adjusted dataset could help quantify that contribution.

Assumptions: Selected endpoints are transparent; explore alternate periods and the full series in the linked tool.

Limitations: No size series is joined here. Dividing separately reported median price and median area would not produce the observed median price per square foot. Coverage varies by series: annual CPI begins in 1913, home prices in 1963, household income in 1967. BLS monthly prices retain their actual inception dates. BLS monthly observations extend through October 2026; annual comparisons use completed published years through 2025. BLS source reuse and average-price methodology were reviewed against archived official guidance. Average prices reflect changing product mixes and are not constant-quality indexes. Historical mortgage-rate data and the related national financing claim are excluded from this release pending reuse clearance. Private mortgage calculations use only rates you enter.

Data periods: 2016 and 2025 annual estimates. Reviewed 2026-11-15. Source records checked: 2026-11-15.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau / HUD — New Residential Sales: price_cust.xlsx, Annual: https://www.census.gov/construction/nrs/data/series.html

Classification: editorial interpretation of source estimates. Receipt method 1.1.0; calculation method 1.0.0.

Full evidence, source locators and data: https://backinmypay.com/evidence/release-2026-11-15-b7a8083e2af0/1.1.0/claim/bigger-houses-do-not-settle-it

Explore the comparison and assumptions.Reproduce it. Give the assumptions a cross-examination.

Initial inputs reproduce the test above, using release release-2026-11-15-b7a8083e2af0 and method 1.0.0. Any amounts you change stay in your browser.

Compare two periods using nominal prices, inflation and available income measures.Back in your day? Excellent. Pick a year. The receipt can take it from here.

Initial example: U.S. new-home prices, 2016–2025. Choose any supported periods below.

Available: 1963–2025. Missing periods are excluded.
Available: 1963–2025. Missing periods are excluded.

Your price comparisonThe price tag has some explaining to do.

Price at the time · 2016$307,800.00The published price estimate for this item and unit in 2016, before adjusting for inflation.
Price at the time · 2025$417,400.00The published price estimate for this item and unit in 2025, before adjusting for inflation.
Starting price in 2025 dollars$412,879.86What the starting price would equal in 2025 money if it had changed with overall consumer prices.
Change beyond general inflation1.1%How far the ending price is above (+) or below (−) the starting price after allowing for general inflation.
Price / annual household income5.213× → 4.772×How many years of before-tax household income equal the price. These are separate population figures, not an actual household’s budget or years of savings.
Price change before inflation adjustment35.6%How much the price rose (+) or fell (−) between the two periods, before allowing for general inflation.
Change in price / household-income ratio-8.5%Positive means the price takes a larger share of household income; negative means a smaller share. This is a percent change in the ratio, not percentage points or an actual household’s burden.

The longer receipt

New-home sale price, full supported series. Nominal dollars. Vertical axis starts at zero. Gaps mean missing data.

$434,500.0019632025
Accessible data table (63 observations)
New-home sale price · nominal · USD
PeriodValue
1963$18,000.00
1964$18,900.00
1965$20,000.00
1966$21,400.00
1967$22,700.00
1968$24,700.00
1969$25,600.00
1970$23,400.00
1971$25,200.00
1972$27,600.00
1973$32,500.00
1974$35,900.00
1975$39,300.00
1976$44,200.00
1977$48,800.00
1978$55,700.00
1979$62,900.00
1980$64,600.00
1981$68,900.00
1982$69,300.00
1983$75,300.00
1984$79,900.00
1985$84,300.00
1986$92,000.00
1987$104,500.00
1988$112,500.00
1989$120,000.00
1990$122,900.00
1991$120,000.00
1992$121,500.00
1993$126,500.00
1994$130,000.00
1995$133,900.00
1996$140,000.00
1997$146,000.00
1998$152,500.00
1999$161,000.00
2000$169,000.00
2001$175,200.00
2002$187,600.00
2003$195,000.00
2004$221,000.00
2005$240,900.00
2006$246,500.00
2007$247,900.00
2008$232,100.00
2009$216,700.00
2010$221,800.00
2011$227,200.00
2012$245,200.00
2013$268,900.00
2014$288,500.00
2015$294,200.00
2016$307,800.00
2017$323,100.00
2018$326,400.00
2019$321,500.00
2020$330,900.00
2021$383,500.00
2022$434,500.00
2023$428,600.00
2024$420,300.00
2025$417,400.00
What’s on this receipt?
What this measures
Publisher annual national median sales price, in dollars. New privately owned single-family houses sold. median; USD.
Data period
2016, 2025 · archive, not live data
Source
U.S. Census Bureau / HUD · NRS annual median
Last checked
2026-11-15 Source retrieval dates, not dataset-release creation.
Publication dates
6 of 6 source observations have no recorded publication date.
Comparison basis and limits
New privately owned single-family houses sold; not existing homes or starter homes. Survey estimates are subject to sampling error and revision. Housing size, location and quality mix change. Coverage varies by series: annual CPI begins in 1913, home prices in 1963, household income in 1967. BLS monthly prices retain their actual inception dates. BLS monthly observations extend through October 2026; annual comparisons use completed published years through 2025. BLS source reuse and average-price methodology were reviewed against archived official guidance. Average prices reflect changing product mixes and are not constant-quality indexes. Historical mortgage-rate data and the related national financing claim are excluded from this release pending reuse clearance. Private mortgage calculations use only rates you enter.
Exact source locators
  • home · 2016 · Annual!B60; year A60 · Publisher annual median; not an average of monthly medians.
  • home · 2025 · Annual!B69; year A69 · Publisher annual median; not an average of monthly medians.
  • cpi · 2016 · #table0; CUUR0000SA0; 2016/Annual ·
  • cpi · 2025 · #table0; CUUR0000SA0; 2025/Annual ·
  • income · 2016 · h05!C20; All Races; row label 2016 · For duplicate years, first published row uses newer processing/population controls; alternate row is not averaged.
  • income · 2025 · h05!C10; All Races; row label 2025 · For duplicate years, first published row uses newer processing/population controls; alternate row is not averaged.

Bring receipts.

Share the comparison and its context.For the group chat’s next unsolicited economics lecture.

One short paragraph. One source link. Ready for the conversation. The full receipt below keeps the details.

Public benchmark selections only. This link pins the data and calculation version.

More formats
Reproducible evidence page

New-home sale price: $307,800.00 in 2016, versus $417,400.00 in 2025. For perspective, that earlier price would be $412,879.86 in 2025 dollars after general inflation. The price went from 5.213 to 4.772 times annual household income—separately measured statistics, not an actual buyer’s budget. These are national new-home medians, not local starter-home prices; size, location and financing matter too. Source: Back In My Pay — https://backinmypay.com/evidence/release-2026-11-15-b7a8083e2af0/1.0.0/home/2016/2025
Full receipt and sources
New-home sale price: 2016 to 2025

US · median · New privately owned single-family houses sold. The published price was $307,800.00 in 2016 and $417,400.00 in 2025. Nominal price change: 35.6%.

The 2016 price equals $412,879.86 in 2025 CPI-adjusted dollars. Price change beyond general inflation: 1.1%.

Price divided by annual household income: 5.213× in 2016, compared with 4.772× in 2025. These are ratios of separately measured population statistics, not actual household budgets.

Assumptions: matched periods where available; CPI measures general inflation, not the cost of one person's basket.

Limitations:
- Coverage varies by series: annual CPI begins in 1913, home prices in 1963, household income in 1967. BLS monthly prices retain their actual inception dates.
- BLS monthly observations extend through October 2026; annual comparisons use completed published years through 2025.
- BLS source reuse and average-price methodology were reviewed against archived official guidance. Average prices reflect changing product mixes and are not constant-quality indexes.
- Historical mortgage-rate data and the related national financing claim are excluded from this release pending reuse clearance. Private mortgage calculations use only rates you enter.
- New privately owned single-family houses sold; not existing homes or starter homes.
- Survey estimates are subject to sampling error and revision. Housing size, location and quality mix change.
- Separately measured population statistics do not describe the burden of actual buyers.
- Price change is not a causal test or a measure of individual effort.
- Publisher annual median; not an average of monthly medians.
- For duplicate years, first published row uses newer processing/population controls; alternate row is not averaged.

Sources:
- U.S. Census Bureau / HUD — New Residential Sales: price_cust.xlsx, Annual: https://www.census.gov/construction/nrs/data/series.html
- U.S. Census Bureau — CPS ASEC Table H-5, All Races, median current dollars: https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/income-poverty/historical-income-households.html
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics — CPI-U and Average Price Data; BLS public API v2: https://data.bls.gov/pdq/SurveyOutputServlet

Source data periods: 2016, 2025. Source records checked: 2026-11-15.

derived calculation; approved data release. Method 1.0.0.

Full evidence, source locators and data: https://backinmypay.com/evidence/release-2026-11-15-b7a8083e2af0/1.0.0/home/2016/2025