For 2016–2025, more square footage may explain some of the price change, but this series can’t tell us how much. The annual new-home median changes from $307,800 to $417,400 (35.6% nominally). That is not an estimate of the effect of size. Size and quality can explain part of a price difference. A suitable matched or quality-adjusted dataset could help quantify that contribution. No size series is joined here. Dividing separately reported median price and median area would not produce the observed median price per square foot.
Source: Back In My Pay — https://backinmypay.com/evidence/release-2026-11-15-b7a8083e2af0/1.1.0/claim/bigger-houses-do-not-settle-it
Full claim receipt and sources
“New houses are bigger now; that explains the price difference.”
Conclusion: Not established by these data. The price series alone cannot isolate size from land, quality, location and the mix of homes sold. It is not a constant-quality home-price index.
The annual new-home median changes from $307,800 to $417,400 (35.6% nominally). That is not an estimate of the effect of size.
Test: Ask whether the national annual price series identifies how much of the 2016–2025 change is caused by size.
Counterargument: Size and quality can explain part of a price difference. A suitable matched or quality-adjusted dataset could help quantify that contribution.
Assumptions: Selected endpoints are transparent; explore alternate periods and the full series in the linked tool.
Limitations: No size series is joined here. Dividing separately reported median price and median area would not produce the observed median price per square foot. Coverage varies by series: annual CPI begins in 1913, home prices in 1963, household income in 1967. BLS monthly prices retain their actual inception dates. BLS monthly observations extend through October 2026; annual comparisons use completed published years through 2025. BLS source reuse and average-price methodology were reviewed against archived official guidance. Average prices reflect changing product mixes and are not constant-quality indexes. Historical mortgage-rate data and the related national financing claim are excluded from this release pending reuse clearance. Private mortgage calculations use only rates you enter.
Data periods: 2016 and 2025 annual estimates. Reviewed 2026-11-15. Source records checked: 2026-11-15.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau / HUD — New Residential Sales: price_cust.xlsx, Annual: https://www.census.gov/construction/nrs/data/series.html
Classification: editorial interpretation of source estimates. Receipt method 1.1.0; calculation method 1.0.0.
Full evidence, source locators and data: https://backinmypay.com/evidence/release-2026-11-15-b7a8083e2af0/1.1.0/claim/bigger-houses-do-not-settle-it
Explore the comparison and assumptions.Reproduce it. Give the assumptions a cross-examination.
Initial inputs reproduce the test above, using release release-2026-11-15-b7a8083e2af0 and method 1.0.0. Any amounts you change stay in your browser.