BACK IN
MY PAY.
Data status ↗

The evidence drawer

Common claims, examined with evidence.Strong opinions. Supporting documents.

Each card defines a test and gives the strongest relevant counterargument. Each receipt identifies its release, sources and review status.

Not established by these data

“Wages are higher, so people must be better off.”

A nominal raise and a real raise are different quantities. CPI conversion tests general purchasing power, not whether everyone is better off.

Missing context

“Inflation is down, so prices should be back down.”

Positive inflation means the index is still rising, even if the rate of increase is smaller. A lower price level requires negative price change over the chosen interval.

Partly supported in this scenario

“Just stop buying coffee and avocado toast.”

Avoiding an expense contributes real savings. Whether that contribution is enough depends on its size relative to the target.

Not established by these data

“New houses are bigger now; that explains the price difference.”

The price series alone cannot isolate size from land, quality, location and the mix of homes sold. It is not a constant-quality home-price index.

Not established by these data

“A national median tells you what a starter home costs here.”

The national statistic describes new homes sold across the country. It does not identify local starter homes, existing sales or one property.

Missing context

“If the price rose 30%, it takes 30% more income.”

The denominator matters. A change in price does not imply the same change in its share of income.

Not established by these data

“Just average the monthly medians.”

Medians do not combine that way. Use the publisher’s annual statistic; a mean of monthly medians is a different measure.